Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Fannie and Freddie Have Been "Saved" -- Now What?

The former Goldman Sachs employees -- err, the government -- have decided to bail out Fannie and Freddie and the race to call another bottom in equity markets, not to mention housing, is on.

Reality, however, is not a friend of these hopeful bulls.

Let's take a quick scan of the economic landscape and see what issues the latest bailout has solved:

  • The unemployment rate seems to only be going up, and unless the new federal agency charged with keeping tabs on the two mortgage giants is hiring en masse, there won't be much of a change here.
  • The dollar could see its recent rally erased after our trading partners and investors around the world come to terms with the $200 billion the Treasury department just dumped into the blender to cut 50 bps off mortgage rates. And, take note, those are prime, Agency rates, and that's it.
  • The unfortunate reality is that most Americans are still in debt and cannot afford a down payment on a house, a requirement that's yet to be removed.
  • Gas prices have fallen, but not by as much as crude prices. Hurricane season is alive and well, threatening most of the gulf oil rigs. Oil companies are already under pressure from tumultuous markets for their black gold and are not likely inclined to lower prices further.


As painful as it is to admit, Fannie and Freddie probably needed to be bailed out to keep the entire financial market from collapsing but it doesn’t mean we are at “the bottom.”

It takes awhile for a fundamental shift in lending to play its way out and that is what we are in the middle of. The middle class is being squeezed more than ever and consumer credit quality on the whole is not going to start improving tomorrow.

More important than any of these points is we do not know what our friends at the government are going to do with Fannie and Fredie and how long it is going to take them to do it. In fact, trusting the very folks who ran these companies into the ground -- albeit under different leadership -- to turn them around is hardly a comforting proposition.

In the end, we need to remember that you need a good credit score and a down payment to buy a house in the real world. So no matter what a television analyst on TV who makes $500,000 a year tells you, this credit crisis is far from over.

No comments: